How Do We Know When a Stock is Truly Cheap?

 Executive Summary

  • Valuation metrics are a central element of Heartland’s 10 Principles of Value Investing™.
  • Additional analysis using EV/EBITDA allows investment managers to evaluate companies in much the same way private equity investors do.
  • In our view, EV/EBITDA is a useful complement to traditional valuation measures like Price/Earnings, Price/Book, and Price/Cash Flow.

When considering valuation-conscious investing, often the first metric that comes to mind is price/earnings, or P/E. This fundamental measure of value identifies stocks whose share prices are moderate relative to the level of profitability the company is able to record.

Heartland’s investment process, however, is designed to measure valuations from multiple angles in an attempt to screen out outliers that appear cheap based on a single multiple. In addition to our fundamental, company-specific research into an organization’s management, business model, financial soundness, and potential catalysts, we employ a number of valuation metrics to size up a potential addition to a portfolio. In this article we’d like to discuss one of the less–understood valuation measures, the Enterprise Multiple, often expressed as EV/EBITDA.

Understanding the EV/EBITDA Calculation

As the length of the name implies, EV/EBITDA involves a few more elements than P/E:

Enterprise Value (EV) = Market Capitalization + Debt and other liabilities – Cash and Cash Equivalents

EBITDA = Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation, and Amortization

By incorporating both the debt a company has incurred and the cash it has on hand, Enterprise Value reflects a company’s assets as well as its liabilities, and suggests the approximate price it would take to acquire the company as a whole. The price used in establishing a P/E ratio, in contrast, simply indicates the company’s share price.

Similarly, while the earnings figure used in P/E is calculated after all expenses, cash and non–cash, are deducted, EBITDA reflects the actual cash flow a company generates from operations. Thus it provides a somewhat different perspective.

To get a picture of just how EV/EBITDA helps to clarify whether a company genuinely represents an attractive value, let’s consider an example we encountered recently of two firms—one is a leading producer of plant based foods and beverages and the other is the top processor and distributor of milk in the U.S. The WhiteWave Foods Company (WWAV) manufactures and distributes products under the brands Silk®, Land O’Lakes®, and International Delight, among others, and Dean Foods Company (DF) processes and distributes dairy products, juices and water under 50 local and regional brands. How do their valuations stack up?

For starters, WhiteWave’s share price (as of 1/31/2017) was $55.06, while Dean’s was $19.86. This put WhiteWave’s market capitalization near $9.7 billion, and Dean’s at $1.8 billion.

Estimates for WhiteWave’s fiscal 2017 earnings per share stand near $1.62, meaning its stock price reflected a forward 2017 P/E of 33.99x. We expect Dean to produce earnings of about $1.57 per share during the same period, giving it a forward 2017 P/E of 12.65x. In looking at these stocks purely on a P/E basis, Dean appears to be more attractively valued.

Digging a Little Deeper

To get a more robust picture of which company is the more compelling investment, we need to consider the different levels of debt carried by the two businesses. WhiteWave has about $2.6 billion in net debt which, when added to its market cap, gives it an Enterprise Value around $11.8 billion. Dean has net debt of approximately $900 million, leading to an Enterprise Value of about $2.7 billion.

With respect to EBITDA, WhiteWave is expected to generate about $674 million in fiscal 2017, while our estimates for Dean run at about $459 million. Thus, the EV/ EBITDA ratios for the two companies varied widely:

WhiteWave: $11.83 billion EV/$674 million EBITDA = 17.53x 2017 Enterprise Multiple

Dean: $2.66 billion EV/$459 million EBITDA = 5.79x 2017 Enterprise Multiple

By this measure, Dean looks even cheaper than its P/E initially indicated.

Comparing WhiteWave and Dean
  WhiteWave Foods Company (WWAV) Dean Foods Company (DF)
Share Price $55.06 $19.86
Market Cap $9.76 billion $1.80 billion
Earnings Per Share (forward 2017) $1.62 $1.57
P/E (forward 2017) 33.99x 12.65x
Net Debt $2.64 billion $904 million
Enterprise Value $11.83 billion $2.66 billion
EBITDA (forward 2017) $674 million $459 million
Net Debt/EBITDA (forward 2017) 3.92x 1.97x
EV/EBITDA (forward 2017) 17.53x 5.79x

Source: FactSet Research Systems Inc., as of 1/31/2017

The question that logically followed was this: Why pay a higher multiple for a potentially riskier asset? Holding Dean was an easy decision, which this examination revealed to be trading at a relative bargain.

Looking More Broadly

This approach to examining a stock is consistent with the level of scrutiny applied by private-equity buyers or other companies seeking an acquisition. We believe using this technique helps us uncover businesses trading at a discount to their intrinsic value and ones that will be attractive to investors and acquirers alike. That’s what we care about.

Please wait while we gather your results.

Author

Heartland Advisors Value Investing Portfolio Manager Bradford A. Evans

Bradford A. Evans

Evans, CFA, is Senior Vice President and Portfolio Manager of the Value Plus Fund and its corresponding separately managed account strategy. He has 21 years of industry experience, 18 at Heartland.

Why Stay the Course?

Applying the key EV/EBITDA metric to the Heartland Value Plus Fund reveals an attractively priced portfolio relative to the market.

  • Consolidation multiples—the average valuations at which companies are being acquired by private-equity funds or by other companies—have been as high as 20x, depending on the industry.
     
  • For the Value Plus Fund, however, the weighted average estimated 2017 Enterprise Multiple is just 10.2x, an indicator of strong cash flows as well as modest valuations*.
     
  • We believe our ability to identify stocks trading well below private market value is particularly advantageous at a time like this, when takeover activity has been strong.

Email Sign Up

  • I am a financial professional or institutional investor
  • I am an individual investor
Financial Professionals & Institutional Investors
Individual Investors

Name

Email

 

Heartland Perspectives

Heartland Perspectives


Product Insights

Select Value Fund

Mid Cap Value Fund

Value Plus Fund

Value Fund

International Value Fund

Opportunistic Value Equity Strategy

Mid Cap Value Strategy

Small Cap Value Plus Strategy

Small Cap Value Strategy

Terms of Use
These email lists are created for use by U.S. investment professionals only and are published strictly for informational purposes. Providing access to the content of these emails does not explicitly or implicitly constitute a solicitation of services or products of Heartland Advisors, Heartland Funds, or any of their affiliates. The information contained in these emails is not intended for distribution to, or for use by, investment professionals in a jurisdiction where distribution or purchase is not authorized. The information contained in these emails is not appropriate for use by individual investors. By registering for any of these emails, you agree to Heartland’s terms and conditions and that you are qualified as an institutional investor or otherwise member of a registered broker/dealer, registered investment advisor, or investment consulting firm.
I agree to the Terms of Use and confirm that I am a financial professional

Monthly enews

©2017 Heartland Advisors | 789 N. Water Street, Suite 500, Milwaukee, WI 53202 | Business Office: 414-347-7777 | Financial Professionals: 888-505-5180 | Individual Investors: 800-432-7856

*Source: FactSet Research Systems, Inc., as of 12/31/2016

Past performance does not guarantee future results.

An investor should consider the Funds’ investment objectives, risks, and charges and expenses carefully before investing or sending money. This and other important information may be found in the prospectus (pdf). To obtain a print prospectus, call 800-432-7856. Please read the prospectus carefully before investing.

The Value Plus Fund invests in small companies that are generally less liquid and more volatile than large companies. The Fund also invests in a smaller number of stocks (generally 40 to 70) than the average mutual fund. The performance of these holdings generally will increase the volatility of the Fund’s returns.

Value investments are subject to the risk that their intrinsic value may not be recognized by the broad market.

The statements and opinions expressed in the articles or appearances are those of the presenter. Any discussion of investments and investment strategies represents the presenters' views as of the date created and are subject to change without notice. The opinions expressed are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. The specific securities discussed, which are intended to illustrate the advisor’s investment style, do not represent all of the securities purchased, sold, or recommended by the advisor for client accounts, and the reader should not assume that an investment in these securities was or would be profitable in the future. Certain security valuations and forward estimates are based on Heartland Advisors’ calculations. Any forecasts may not prove to be true.

As of 12/31/2016, Dean Foods Company and The WhiteWave Foods Company represented 1.02% and 0.00% of the Value Plus Fund’s net assets, respectively.

Portfolio holdings are subject to change without notice. Current and future portfolio holdings are subject to risk. View full holdings as of the most recent quarter end.

The above individual is a registered representative of ALPS Distributors, Inc.

CFA® is a registered trademark owned by the CFA Institute.

Heartland’s investing glossary provides definitions for several terms used on this page.

The Heartland Funds are distributed by ALPS Distributors, Inc.

ALPS Distributors, Inc., is not affiliated with Heartland Advisors.

top